The word pulsed on the silk like a heartbeat made visible.
Brother.
Yu Yan stared at the handprint glowing within the thangka, and understanding came to him not as a revelation but as a slow, cold settling of pieces into place. The word was not a message from Cuyen. It was a message from the painting itself—or from whatever the painting had become. The curse was no longer simply a weapon. It was a presence. A consciousness. Something that had been fed by fifteen years of hatred and was now hungry to be born.
He rose from the prayer cushion, his knees aching, his heart pounding. The shrine felt different now. The incense smoke curled in patterns that seemed almost deliberate. The oil lamps flickered in a rhythm that matched the pulsing of the tendrils. The air itself was thick, charged, as if a thunderstorm was gathering in the space between the walls.
He needed to work. He needed to finish the counter-painting before the tendrils reached the edge. But he also needed to understand what the thangka was becoming—what Cuyen had truly created—because the rules of the game had changed, and he did not yet know the new rules.
The door opened behind him. Two soldiers entered, followed by a eunuch in gray silk who carried a tray of food and tea. The eunuch set the tray on a low table and withdrew without meeting Yu Yan's eyes. The soldiers remained, their faces impassive.
"Eat," one of them said. "The Fourth Beile's orders. You will need your strength."
Yu Yan looked at the food—steamed fish, pickled vegetables, a bowl of rice, a pot of tea. It was the finest meal he had been offered in weeks. He felt no hunger at all, but he forced himself to eat, because the soldier was right. He needed his strength. Whatever was coming, he would face it on his feet or not at all.
As he ate, the door opened again, and Wen Qing entered.
She looked exhausted. Her robes were rumpled, her hair escaping from its pins, her hands stained with pigments of a dozen different colors. But her eyes were sharp and alert, and she carried a bundle wrapped in oiled cloth that Yu Yan recognized immediately.
"The counter-painting," she said, setting the bundle on the floor. "I brought everything. The manuscript, the pigments, the tools. The Fourth Beile's men helped me transport it."
"You have been working on it?"
"Every moment since you were taken. The silver layer is complete. The underdrawing is sealed. All that remains is the final layer—the counter-characters, the binding strokes that will activate the mirror." She knelt beside the bundle and began unwrapping it. "But there is something you need to see before we continue."
She drew out the original thangka—the one from the Eastern Residence, the one that had been hanging in Yu Yan's room at the inn. She unrolled it on the floor beside the palace thangka, and Yu Yan saw immediately what she meant.
The two paintings were identical in composition, but they were no longer identical in content. The palace thangka—the one hanging in the shrine—bore the handprint and the word "brother." But the inn thangka—the one Yu Yan had carried with him, the one that was bound directly to his own life force—now bore different words.
It read: "The mirror is the door."
"What does that mean?" Yu Yan asked.
"I have been trying to understand it since it appeared, three hours ago." Wen Qing traced the characters with her finger. "The manuscript speaks of the mirror of colors as a technique for canceling curses. But it also speaks of the mirror as a threshold. A passage between one state and another. What if the counter-painting is not simply a weapon? What if it is a gate?"
"A gate to where?"
"To wherever the curse originates. To the source of its power." Wen Qing looked up at him, and her expression was troubled. "Cuyen has been imprisoned for fifteen years. He has had no access to the shamans who were purged, no access to the texts that were burned. Where did he learn to create a curse like this? Who taught him? The power has to come from somewhere."
Yu Yan thought of the genealogy scroll in Shen's library, the black paint scratched away to reveal the name beneath. He thought of Cuyen's eyes, ancient and weary and burning. He thought of the wolf seal that Hong Taiji had shown him, the symbol of a lineage that had been erased but not destroyed.
"The ancestors," he said. "The thirteen generations before Nurhaci. The old shamans. The ones who practiced the forbidden arts before the monks came. Cuyen did not learn the curse from a living teacher. He learned it from the dead."
"How?"
"I do not know. But the thangka keeps changing. It keeps speaking. Words appear that neither I nor Cuyen painted. Something is using the painting to communicate. Something that is not human."
Wen Qing was silent for a long moment. Then she unrolled the counter-painting beside the two thangkas. The silver surface gleamed in the lamplight, a perfect mirror that reflected the shrine's interior with ghostly fidelity.
"If the mirror is a door," she said, "then the counter-painting is not just a cure. It is a passage. When we complete it, something will come through. Something that has been waiting."
"Then we have a choice. We can complete the counter-painting and open the door, not knowing what will emerge. Or we can refuse, and let the curse kill the Khan and me."
"Not much of a choice."
"It is the only one we have."
Yu Yan knelt before the counter-painting and began to prepare his materials. The final layer, according to the manuscript, required a mixture of all the pigments they had used—hematite and indigo, silver and lampblack, cinnabar and malachite, all bound together with animal glue and water from a north-facing well. The mixture would be used to paint the counter-characters, the symbols that would reflect the original curse back upon itself.
But which characters to paint? The original thangka contained fifteen curse marks—the fourteen targeting Cuyen's brothers, and the fifteenth targeting the Khan. The counter-painting was supposed to contain fifteen counter-marks, each one the mirror of its corresponding curse. But the thangka had changed. New characters had appeared. "Painter." "Counter-painter." "Trap." "Brother." "The mirror is the door." These were not part of the original design. They were additions, modifications, messages from whatever intelligence was using the paintings to speak.
"I cannot simply copy the original counter-characters," Yu Yan said. "The curse has evolved. The counter-curse must evolve with it, or it will fail."
"How do we evolve it?"
"I do not know." Yu Yan set down his brush. "The manuscript gives precise instructions for a specific curse. But this curse is no longer specific. It is alive. It is changing. If I follow the instructions exactly, I may complete the trap that Cuyen has set. If I deviate, I may destroy any chance of the counter-curse working."
"Then we need to understand the trap before we spring it." Wen Qing pulled the copied manuscript pages from her sleeve and spread them on the floor. "The warning in the footnote—it said that the painter who creates a counter-curse binds their fate to both paintings. What if that binding works both ways? What if the curse's creator is also bound?"
"Cuyen?"
"Cuyen, and whoever taught him. The ancestors. The source of the power. If the mirror reflects everything, it should reflect the entire chain of creation, not just the painter."
Yu Yan looked at the three paintings arrayed before him. The palace thangka, with its handprint and its single glowing word. The inn thangka, with its cryptic message about the mirror. The counter-painting, silver and silent, waiting to be completed. They formed a triangle on the shrine floor, and in the lamplight, their surfaces seemed to shimmer in unison, as if they were already connected by threads of light that only the paintings could see.
"The trap," he said slowly. "Cuyen wants me to complete the counter-painting. He has been guiding me toward it from the beginning. The manuscript in Shen's library. The handprint on my wall. The changing characters. He wants me to paint the final strokes. Why?"
"Because he cannot complete the counter-curse himself," Wen Qing said. "Only the painter of the original curse can paint the counter-curse. It has to be you. And if the counter-painting is a door, he wants you to open it. He wants something to come through."
"The ancestors."
"The ancestors who were purged. The shamans who were executed. The old powers that Nurhaci tried to eradicate when he adopted Buddhism and declared himself Khan. Cuyen is not just trying to kill his father. He is trying to undo everything his father built. He is trying to bring back the old ways."
Yu Yan understood then. The scope of Cuyen's ambition was far larger than he had imagined. This was not merely a son's revenge against a father who had imprisoned him. This was a restoration. A return to the world that had existed before the Manchus became an empire, before the shamans were replaced by monks, before the wolf totem was replaced by the dragon. Cuyen was not just killing the Khan. He was killing the future.
And Yu Yan was the instrument. The brush that would paint the door. The hand that would open it.
"What happens if I refuse?" he asked. "If I simply do not complete the counter-painting?"
"The curse kills you. The Khan dies. Cuyen wins. And without the counter-painting, there is no door—the ancestors remain trapped, wherever they are. Cuyen's larger plan fails, but his immediate goal succeeds."
"And if I complete the counter-painting, and the door opens, and the ancestors come through?"
"Then the old powers return. The shamans regain their influence. The Buddhist institutions that Nurhaci built are torn down. The empire is plunged into chaos." Wen Qing met his eyes. "But you might live. And the Khan might live. The mirror reflects the curse—it should neutralize the immediate threat to both of you."
"Should. Might. We are gambling with forces we do not understand."
"That is what it means to paint a curse. You told me yourself—when you painted the hidden characters in the Eastern Residence, you believed in what you were doing. Belief is the engine of magic. If you believe the counter-curse will work, it will work. If you doubt, it will fail."
Yu Yan looked down at his hands. The scar on his left thumb, worn into the flesh by decades of holding a brush. The faint tremor that had been growing stronger as the curse advanced. The ink stains that never fully washed away, the permanent marks of his profession. These hands had created the weapon that was killing the Khan. Now they would create the weapon that might save him—or damn the empire.
He picked up his brush.
"Tell me the counter-characters," he said. "All of them. Not just the fifteen from the original curse. The new ones too. 'Painter.' 'Counter-painter.' 'Trap.' 'Brother.' 'The mirror is the door.' I will paint them all. I will paint the door, and I will paint the key, and I will paint whatever comes through."
Wen Qing opened her mouth to argue, then closed it. She understood. The only way to spring a trap safely was to know exactly where it was and exactly what it would do. By painting the new characters into the counter-curse, Yu Yan was not avoiding the trap. He was incorporating it. Making it part of the mirror. Turning Cuyen's own weapon against him.
"Then let us begin," she said.
The painting took seven hours.
Yu Yan worked in silence, his brush moving across the silver surface with the precision of a man who had nothing left to lose. The counter-characters were intricate, each one a mirror image of its corresponding curse, each one painted with the mixed pigments that contained all the colors of the original. Hematite and cinnabar. Indigo and malachite. Silver and gold. The brush moved, and the characters appeared, and the counter-painting grew darker and more complex with each stroke.
Wen Qing worked beside him, grinding fresh pigment when the mixture ran low, chanting the Heart Sutra in a low, steady voice. The words filled the shrine like incense smoke, invisible but pervasive, a reminder that even in the midst of magic, there was still the dharma, still the teachings of the Buddha, still a path through the darkness.
The soldiers outside changed shifts twice. The eunuch brought more food, which no one ate. The oil lamps burned down and were refilled. The incense was replenished. The world outside the shrine continued its ordinary course, indifferent to the battle being waged within.
As the hours passed, Yu Yan felt the curse weakening. It was a subtle change at first—a loosening of the pressure in his chest, a clearing of the fog at the edges of his thoughts. But as the counter-painting grew, as each new character was laid upon the silver, the tendrils on the original thangkas began to recede.
It was working. The mirror was reflecting. The curse was being canceled, stroke by stroke.
But something else was happening too. Something that Yu Yan had not anticipated.
The counter-painting was becoming beautiful.
Not beautiful in the way of ordinary art—the pleasing arrangement of colors, the satisfying balance of composition. It was beautiful in a way that hurt to look at, beautiful in a way that made Yu Yan's breath catch and his eyes burn. The silver surface, overlaid with the dark mixture of pigments, had taken on a depth that was almost three-dimensional. The characters seemed to float above the silk, suspended in a space that did not quite exist in the physical world. And in the center of the painting, where the final counter-character would go, a shape was beginning to form—a shape that Yu Yan had not painted.
It was a face. Indistinct, blurred, as if seen through water. But unmistakably a face. And it was looking at him.
"The door is opening," Wen Qing whispered. "Do you see it?"
"I see it."
"Keep painting. You must finish before it fully opens. The counter-characters are the lock. Without them, whatever comes through will be unbound."
Yu Yan kept painting. His hand was steady now, steadier than it had been in weeks. The curse's grip on him was fading, and his strength was returning. But with the strength came a growing dread, because the face in the silver was becoming clearer with each stroke, and he was beginning to recognize it.
It was his own face.
No—not quite his own. The features were similar, but older, more weathered, the eyes deeper and darker. The face of a man who had suffered more than Yu Yan had suffered, who had lived longer and lost more. The face of a man who had been dead for a long time.
"The ancestors," Yu Yan said, and his voice was barely a whisper. "They are not coming from outside. They are coming from inside. From the blood. From the lineage. Cuyen is not summoning the old shamans—he is becoming them. The curse is not a weapon. It is a transformation."
"Then the counter-painting is not stopping the transformation. It is completing it."
"No." Yu Yan set down his brush. There was only one character left to paint—the final counter-character, the one that would seal the mirror and activate the full reflection. "The counter-painting is a mirror. It reflects what it faces. If Cuyen is transforming, the mirror will transform me too. That is the trap. That is what he wanted all along. Not to kill me. To make me like him. A vessel for the ancestors. A door for the old powers."
"Then do not paint the final character. Leave the counter-painting incomplete."
"If I leave it incomplete, the curse resumes its work. The Khan dies. I die. Cuyen's transformation continues unopposed." Yu Yan looked at the face in the silver, the face that was his and not his, the face that was waiting for him to make his choice. "The only way to stop Cuyen is to complete the mirror. But completing the mirror means becoming what he has become."
"There must be another way."
"There is not. This is the game he has been playing from the beginning. Every move I have made, every desperate gambit, every clever trick—all of it has led to this moment. He is giving me the same choice he was given, fifteen years ago. Sacrifice myself, or let everything I care about be destroyed."
Wen Qing was silent for a long time. Then she reached out and took Yu Yan's hand—the hand that held the brush, the hand that had painted the curse and the counter-curse and everything in between.
"What did Cuyen choose?" she asked.
"I do not know. He was imprisoned. He did not die. Perhaps he chose to sacrifice himself, and this is the result—fifteen years in a gilded cage, slowly transforming into something inhuman. Perhaps he refused, and the curse he tried to cast on his brothers rebounded on him instead."
"Then his choice tells us nothing."
"It tells us that neither path leads to a good end." Yu Yan looked at the face in the silver one last time. The eyes were still looking at him, patient and ancient and utterly unafraid. "But one path leads to an end that I choose. The other leads to an end that is chosen for me."
He dipped his brush in the pigment mixture and painted the final character.
The effect was immediate.
Light burst from the counter-painting—not the warm yellow light of the oil lamps, but a cold silver light that filled the shrine like moonlight made solid. The two original thangkas responded in kind, their surfaces erupting with answering light, gold and vermilion and lapis blue. The three paintings formed a triangle of radiance, and in the center of that triangle, something began to take shape.
It was a figure. Tall, indistinct, woven from light and shadow. It had no face, but its posture was familiar—the slight forward lean of a man who had spent too many years hunched over a writing desk. Its hands were the hands of a painter, the fingers long and elegant, the thumb bearing the faint mark of a brush-holding scar.
"Father," Wen Qing breathed. "Father, is that you?"
The figure did not answer in words. But it turned toward her, and in its turning there was a tenderness that needed no speech.
The door was open. The mirror was active. And through it, the dead were returning—not as ghosts, not as ancestors seeking to restore the old ways, but as memories. As presences. As the accumulated weight of all the art that had ever been made, all the pigments that had ever been ground, all the brushes that had ever touched silk.
Yu Yan understood then. The curse had never been about the ancestors. It had been about Cuyen himself—his loneliness, his isolation, his desperate need to connect with something beyond the walls of his cage. He had reached into the old magic not to destroy his father's empire, but to find a family that would not betray him. The ancestors he had summoned were not the shamans of legend. They were the spirits of everyone who had ever been erased, everyone who had ever been imprisoned, everyone who had ever been told that they did not exist.
Including Cuyen himself.
The light faded. The figure dissolved. The three paintings lay still on the shrine floor, their surfaces quiet, their tendrils gone. The curse was broken. The counter-curse was complete.
But Yu Yan did not feel victorious. He felt hollow, emptied out, as if something essential had been taken from him in the moment of completion. He looked at his hands, and they were still his hands, but they felt different. Lighter. As if the scar on his thumb was no longer just a scar, but a door through which something had passed.
"It is done," Wen Qing said. Her voice was thick with tears. "The curse is broken. The Khan will recover."
"Will he?"
"The tendrils are gone. The hidden characters have faded. The paintings are just paintings now." She touched the palace thangka, and the gold leaf flaked away beneath her fingers, revealing blank silk beneath. "The magic is gone."
"No." Yu Yan looked at the counter-painting, at the silver surface that had been his mirror. The face was no longer visible, but he could still feel it watching him from somewhere just beyond the visible. "The magic is not gone. It has moved. It is inside me now."
"What do you mean?"
"I painted the final character. I opened the door. Something came through, and it did not go back." He pressed his hand to his chest, where the pressure had been, where the curse had been. The pressure was gone, but something else had taken its place. A presence. A waiting. "I am the door now. That was the trap. Not to kill me. Not to transform me into an ancestor. To make me the threshold through which the old powers can enter the world whenever they choose."
Wen Qing's face went pale. "Then Cuyen has won."
"Has he?" Yu Yan stood, his legs unsteady but holding. He walked to the door of the shrine and slid it open. The soldiers outside straightened to attention, their hands on their swords. Beyond them, the corridors of the palace stretched away into shadow.
"Cuyen wanted a door," Yu Yan said. "But a door opens both ways. If the old powers can come through me, I can go through to them. I can find Cuyen—not his body in the Eastern Residence, but his spirit, his essence, whatever part of him has been reaching through the paintings. I can find him, and I can end this."
"You do not know that. You do not know what is on the other side."
"No." Yu Yan turned back to look at her, and for the first time in weeks, he smiled—a thin, tired smile, but a real one. "But I know what is on this side. A dying Khan. A prince who will stop at nothing to destroy his family. An empire balanced on the edge of a blade. If I can change any of that, it is worth the risk."
"Then I am coming with you."
"You cannot. You are not bound to the paintings. You are not the door." He walked back to her and took her hands, the same hands that had ground pigments and mixed colors and held him steady when he was falling apart. "You are the witness, Wen Qing. The one who remembers. If I do not return, someone must tell the world what happened here. Someone must make sure that Cuyen's story is not erased the way he tried to erase his father."
Wen Qing's eyes were bright with tears, but she did not let them fall. "I will remember. I will tell them. I swear it."
Yu Yan nodded. Then he turned to the soldiers at the door.
"Take me to the Eastern Residence," he said. "I need to see the prince."
The soldiers looked at each other uncertainly. "The Fourth Beile's orders—"
"The Fourth Beile wants his father to live. He wants the curse to be broken. I am the only one who can ensure both. Take me to Cuyen, or explain to your master why you refused."
The soldiers hesitated a moment longer. Then one of them nodded and gestured for Yu Yan to follow.
The journey to the Eastern Residence took them through streets that were quiet in the gray light of early morning. The city was waking, but slowly, as if it sensed that something had changed in the night. The bannermen at the intersections watched Yu Yan pass with expressions that were unreadable. The citizens in their doorways looked away.
The Eastern Residence was unchanged. The same whitewashed walls, the same clean-swept courtyards, the same guards with their flat, incurious eyes. The steward with the face like folded parchment met Yu Yan at the gate and led him through the silent corridors without a word.
Cuyen was in the studio. He was sitting at the rosewood table, exactly as he had been in Yu Yan's dream. A brush was in his hand. A length of silk was spread before him. He did not look up when Yu Yan entered.
"You came back," Cuyen said. "I knew you would."
"The counter-painting is complete. The curse is broken. Your father will live."
"I know. I felt it happen." Cuyen set down his brush and turned to face Yu Yan. His face was younger than it had been during their first meeting, smoother, less lined. But his eyes were the same—ancient, weary, burning. "I also felt the door open. You are the threshold now. The passage. The bridge between what was and what will be."
"That was your plan from the beginning. Not to kill the Khan. Not to restore the ancestors. To make me into this."
"Not you specifically. Any painter would have served. But you were the one who came. You were the one who painted with conviction. You were the one who believed." Cuyen smiled, and there was something almost gentle in the expression. "I have been alone for fifteen years. The only prisoner in a jail that has no other inmates. The only worshipper in a temple that has no other congregants. I needed someone who could understand what I had become. Someone who could share the burden."
"The burden of being a door?"
"The burden of being erased. Of being removed from the genealogy. Of being told, every day, that you do not exist." Cuyen stood and walked to the latticed window, gazing out at the darkening courtyard. "I did not want to kill my father. I wanted him to see me. To acknowledge me. To admit that I am still his son. But he will not. He cannot. The empire he has built depends on my erasure. If I exist, the succession is contested. If I exist, the dynasty is divided. So I must not exist."
"That is why you created the curse. Not to kill, but to communicate."
"The curse was a message. A painting that could speak. A handprint that said 'Return.' A face in the silver that said 'I am here.' I was not trying to destroy the empire. I was trying to make it look at me."
Yu Yan looked around the studio—the rosewood table, the silk scrolls, the brushes and inkstones. It was a room designed for creation, but it had become a room for imprisonment. Cuyen had been painting messages for fifteen years, and no one had answered. Until now.
"I see you," Yu Yan said.
Cuyen turned from the window. His eyes were wet, but his face was composed. "I know. That is why I chose you. Not because you are a skilled painter, though you are. Because you are a man who understands what it means to be used. To be a tool in someone else's hand. To have your art turned into a weapon without your consent."
"What happens now?"
"Now you make a choice. The door is open. You can step through it—fully, completely, leaving your body behind—and join me in the space between. Together, we can be the threshold. Together, we can ensure that no one is ever erased again. Or you can close the door. Seal it permanently. Trap me on the other side, alone, forever." Cuyen met his eyes. "I am giving you the choice I never had. The choice my father never gave me."
Yu Yan thought of Wen Qing, waiting in the palace shrine. He thought of the Khan, recovering in his chambers. He thought of Hong Taiji, the calculating prince who had offered him a future. He thought of the face in the silver, the face that was his and not his, the face that had been waiting for him to arrive.
He thought of the silence. The silence of the Eastern Residence, the silence of the prison, the silence of a world that had forgotten how to listen. And he thought of what he had told Wen Qing: that a door opens both ways.
"I will not join you," he said. "And I will not trap you. The door will remain open. But I will be its guardian, not its prisoner. I will decide what passes through and what does not. I will ensure that the old powers do not overwhelm the new, and that the new does not erase the old. I will be the balance."
Cuyen stared at him. "That is not one of the choices."
"It is now. I am the painter. I am the door. I set the terms."
"You do not have the power—"
"I have all the power. You gave it to me when you made me the threshold. The door obeys its maker. And I am the maker now."
Cuyen's face twisted through a dozen emotions—anger, disbelief, desperation, and finally, something that looked like relief. "Fifteen years. Fifteen years I have waited for someone to say those words. Someone who would not be my enemy, and would not be my servant. Someone who would simply be my equal."
"I am not your equal. I am your counter-painter. Your mirror. Your reflection. I am what you made me, and I am what I made myself." Yu Yan walked to the door of the studio and paused on the threshold. "You will remain here, in the Eastern Residence. You will not attempt to contact the outside world. You will not create any more curses. And in exchange, you will not be alone. I will visit you. I will speak with you. I will ensure that someone, at least, knows that you exist."
"And if I refuse?"
"Then I will close the door. And you will be truly alone. Forever."
Cuyen was silent for a long time. Then he nodded, a single, slow inclination of his head. "I accept."
Yu Yan left the Eastern Residence without looking back. The morning sun had risen while he was inside, and the city was bright with the cold light of late autumn. The guards at the gate watched him pass with expressions that were no longer flat—there was something in their eyes now, something that might have been curiosity, or respect, or fear.
He walked through the streets, past the craftsmen's quarter, past the painting guild, past the inn where he had slept with a handprint on his wall and a curse in his heart. He walked until he reached Wen Qing's workshop, where she was waiting, just as he knew she would be.
"It is done?" she asked.
"It is done. Cuyen will not trouble the empire again. The Khan will recover. The succession will proceed as the fates decree."
"And you? What will you do?"
Yu Yan looked at his hands—the scar on his thumb, the ink stains, the faint tremor that had not entirely faded. "I will paint. I will guard the door. I will ensure that the old powers and the new find a way to coexist. And I will remember."
"Remember what?"
"Everything. The curse. The counter-curse. The face in the silver. The handprint on the wall. The silence of the Eastern Residence. All of it." He looked up at the sky, where clouds were gathering, heavy with the promise of rain. "I will remember, and I will paint, and I will wait. Because one day, someone will need to know what happened here. One day, the door will need to be opened again. And when that day comes, I will be ready."
Wen Qing took his hand—the hand that had painted the curse and the counter-curse and everything in between—and held it tightly.
"Then I will wait with you," she said. "Someone has to grind the pigments."
They stood together in the doorway of the workshop, watching the clouds gather and the light change, while somewhere in the Eastern Residence, a prince sat alone in his studio, painting messages that no one would read. And somewhere in the imperial palace, a Khan took his first clear breath in weeks, his lungs free of the weight that had been crushing them. And somewhere beyond the visible world, a door stood open, waiting for whoever would come through it next.
The silence that followed was not the silence of a crime scene. It was the silence of a canvas, stretched and primed and ready to receive the first stroke.


No comments yet. Be the first to comment!